Revenue management, answered
Straight answers for vacation rental managers.
The questions managers actually ask about pricing their portfolios, answered plainly by Jack Murphy, our head of revenue management since 2017.
What is RevPAR and why does it matter for vacation rental managers?
Read the answer →
How do you stop property owners from leaving your vacation rental management company?
Read the answer →
Should a vacation rental manager use dynamic pricing or set prices manually?
Read the answer →
How do you price vacation rentals for shoulder season?
Read the answer →
What is a comp set in vacation rental revenue management?
Read the answer →
How much more revenue can professional revenue management add to a vacation rental?
Read the answer →
What are orphan nights and how should vacation rental managers price them?
Read the answer →
How should vacation rental managers set minimum stay rules?
Read the answer →
What should a vacation rental manager show owners in a monthly report?
Read the answer →
How do you benchmark a vacation rental against its real competition?
Read the answer →
What is the difference between occupancy and RevPAR for short-term rentals?
Read the answer →
How often should vacation rental prices be adjusted?
Read the answer →
How do vacation rental revenue managers charge for their service?
Read the answer →
How should a vacation rental manager set the base price for a new listing?
Read the answer →
Is a revenue management service worth it for a vacation rental manager?
Read the answer →
How do you handle a last-minute cancellation on a vacation rental?
Read the answer →
When the market softens for several weeks, should I lower my minimum nightly prices temporarily or hold them higher to protect my average rate?
Read the answer →
Do seasonal and external market conditions actually affect how my listings perform, or can pricing be managed around them?
Read the answer →
How quickly should I expect a pricing overhaul to improve my booking performance?
Read the answer →
What minimum nightly price should I set for a slow-season market without killing bookings?
Read the answer →
When a listing keeps underperforming, how do I keep from losing the owner whose property it is?
Read the answer →
How do I stop losing owner-clients when their listings underperform on bookings?
Read the answer →
Is my revenue underperformance the actual reason owners are leaving me, or is it something else?
Read the answer →
How do I find better property-owner clients and win higher-quality listings for my portfolio?
Read the answer →
How do I build a predictable pipeline of new owner deals instead of relying on cold outreach?
Read the answer →
How do I compete with the big corporate managers in my market for new owner clients?
Read the answer →
How do I move away from low-fee owners who demand constant hand-holding toward higher-paying, lower-maintenance clients?
Read the answer →
How do I reduce the manual workload of optimizing each listing so I get leverage instead of more labor?
Read the answer →
If I switch pricing providers, will there be downtime, or can pricing start the same day I move off my current setup?
Read the answer →
Should the single-night-stay rule that fills one-night gaps be turned on across my whole portfolio or only on specific listings?
Read the answer →
What assumptions and methodology sit behind a revenue projection, and how do I explain them to my own property owner?
Read the answer →
What revenue increase can I realistically expect, and can you show me the projected numbers before I commit?
Read the answer →
Are projected revenue figures guaranteed, or could the market change and move them?
Read the answer →
How is each of my properties performing versus the comparable listings competing for the same guests in my market?
Read the answer →
What is the proof of the revenue actually captured for my portfolio, listing by listing, since pricing was taken over?
Read the answer →
Why are my listings priced above the market median during a slow month instead of priced to book?
Read the answer →
When my occupancy is low, shouldn't I just drop rates to fill the calendar?
Read the answer →
Why aren't we dropping prices faster instead of inching them down gradually?
Read the answer →
Can I get white-label monthly performance reports I can send to my owners under my own brand to keep them loyal to me?
Read the answer →
A property booked right after a price drop, so doesn't that prove the lower price is the right strategy?
Read the answer →
Can I raise the rate on a specific property given its strong recent booking values?
Read the answer →
Can I hold prices higher on a listing because the owner cares most about achieving a high rate?
Read the answer →
How do I stop one-night orphan gaps in the calendar between bookings?
Read the answer →
Should I change a listing to a new owner or account, or refresh it, to boost its search ranking?
Read the answer →
What is the right comp set for a property, and should I edit the existing one or build a new one?
Read the answer →
Is the market and comp-set radius being used the right reference market for my area when property quality varies a lot across it?
Read the answer →
How does the comp set or percentile benchmark actually get used to set my prices?
Read the answer →
What should the minimum nightly price and minimum-stay rules be for a given property?
Read the answer →
Can you look at my conversion or view-to-booking metrics to explain soft performance?
Read the answer →
Am I leaving money on the table because of a lack of pricing sophistication and strategy?
Read the answer →
Can we set a hard minimum price floor on a listing so it never books below a certain number?
Read the answer →
Can I restrict which days guests are allowed to check in or check out?
Read the answer →
What is the downside of adding more minimum-stay and check-out restrictions to a calendar?
Read the answer →
How should pricing be handled differently for mid-term or long-term rentals versus short-term?
Read the answer →
Why is a listing getting so many short minimum-night stays, and can I enforce a higher minimum stay?
Read the answer →
Can a specific listing be taken off dynamic pricing because we are running it mostly long-term?
Read the answer →
Do long-term and mid-term stays hurt my momentum and ranking on the main booking channel?
Read the answer →
Why did a particular date get priced so low, and can it be corrected?
Read the answer →
How do I explain to a skeptical property owner why their nightly rates are lower than they expect?
Read the answer →
What data can I use to justify a conservative pricing approach to an owner who wants higher rates?
Read the answer →
Are my booked rates actually higher than last year, or am I leaving money on the table?
Read the answer →
Once you adjust for changes in the overall market, am I actually doing better than last year?
Read the answer →
Why is a newer or slow-booking listing not picking up, and what should we do about it?
Read the answer →
How should I price a brand-new listing with no booking history so it gains traction instead of sitting empty?
Read the answer →
Could a minimum-stay or pricing setting have been overwritten when the pricing tool synced with my property management system?
Read the answer →
How do I connect a listing from a non-Airbnb booking channel into the pricing platform?
Read the answer →
Is a sudden booking drop caused by new pricing, or by something broken in my PMS integration?
Read the answer →
Why are my nightly rates showing much higher on the booking channel than they appear in the pricing tool?
Read the answer →
How do I bring my channel markup back down to the standard percentage instead of an inflated one?
Read the answer →
Why do prices sync to some of my listings but not others that revert to my PMS seasonal rules?
Read the answer →
When the pricing tool shows a price, is that my owner's net payout or the amount before the platform fee?
Read the answer →
Why did a recent booking produce an owner payout far lower than expected, and was that price correct?
Read the answer →
If one of my listings has a pricing problem, does it affect all my listings or just that one property?
Read the answer →
Why am I only getting last-minute bookings inside a zero-to-seven-day window and almost nothing booked further out?
Read the answer →
How do I get more far-out, advance bookings on the calendar instead of only short-notice ones?
Read the answer →
How do I price a listing so a new one keeps its position in the OTA search ranking?
Read the answer →
Can I keep length-of-stay discount pricing active alongside dynamic nightly pricing?
Read the answer →
Should I keep my listings priced below market to protect momentum and my OTA position?
Read the answer →
When a guest cancels close to the date, how should I re-price the freed-up nights to rebook them?
Read the answer →
Should two competing listings of different sizes in the same building be priced relative to each other, or independently?
Read the answer →
How far out and how aggressively should I drop weekend and last-minute rates during the slow season to keep occupancy?
Read the answer →
Should I combine multiple similar units under one listing or price each one individually?
Read the answer →
How do I make sure my pricing ladders correctly so a 3-bedroom prices above a 2-bedroom and the 2-bedroom above the 1-bedroom?
Read the answer →
Should a combined or compound listing be priced at a discount to its individual rooms, or should I price each independently first to set a baseline?
Read the answer →
Should owned-but-currently-unmanaged listings be added into the priced portfolio or kept priced manually?
Read the answer →
When a short-term-rental platform moves to a host-only fee structure, what markup do I add in the channel manager so the owner's net payout stays the same?
Read the answer →
When I raise rates after adding a new value proposition, should I push the increase all at once or roll it in gradually?
Read the answer →
How should I re-price cancellations and reopened dates so I capture more revenue on the refilled nights?
Read the answer →
How does day-of-week pricing affect longer stays, and can a mid-tier weekday rate make a multi-night booking too expensive at the total-cost level?
Read the answer →
Am I getting enough extra revenue back to justify what I pay for revenue management each month?
Read the answer →
Should I just learn revenue management myself and bring it in-house as I scale?
Read the answer →
How do I know the pricing is being actively managed by a human expert rather than left to a set-and-forget algorithm?
Read the answer →
How do I make sure an owner-negotiated or manually set rate doesn't get overridden in the background without me knowing?
Read the answer →
Should I price a multi-listing property to stay on short-term rental, or convert a poorly performing unit to a long-term rental instead?
Read the answer →
When I add a new listing, will it automatically be priced and onboarded, and how is it billed?
Read the answer →
Can I get a 12-month look-back and forward-pacing revenue report I can use to win a new owner's business?
Read the answer →
When an owner is selling a property, how should I handle blocked dates for inspections and the risk to existing reservations?
Read the answer →
How do I price a minimum-fee revenue-management offer to convince hesitant self-managing owners to let me run their pricing?
Read the answer →
Can you pull a report on a prospective owner's listings so I can show them the revenue problem and win their account?
Read the answer →
How do other managers mark up a revenue-management service when they resell it to their owners?
Read the answer →
Why are my listings booking far below the minimum nightly price I set?
Read the answer →
How do channel-level discounts stack on top of my pricing settings, and how do I stop double-discounting so my floor price is respected?
Read the answer →
Is a high booking-conversion rate actually good, or could it mean I'm priced too cheap and leaving money on the table?
Read the answer →
Why are my listings underperforming in a saturated market even when my prices look competitive?
Read the answer →
Why are some of my listings performing great while others struggle, and what explains the inconsistency?
Read the answer →
What can I do to fill last-minute vacancies and calendar gaps over peak holiday periods?
Read the answer →
When a listing books up very fast, does that mean it was priced too low and left money on the table?
Read the answer →
Can I charge a guest extra to add nights onto an existing reservation, and how much should the extra night cost?
Read the answer →
Should cleaning fees be adjusted per night, and how does that affect longer versus shorter stays?
Read the answer →
Why is year-over-year revenue a misleading way to judge a vacation rental's performance?
Read the answer →
Why does comparing this month to last month not tell you whether your pricing is working?
Read the answer →
Is it worth running an early-bird or strikethrough-discount promotion on a booking channel, and will it interfere with dynamic pricing?
Read the answer →
What is RevPAR Index and how do vacation rental managers use it?
Read the answer →
How much extra revenue does professional revenue management need to generate to pay for itself?
Read the answer →
How should a vacation rental manager set a baseline to measure pricing performance?
Read the answer →
Why measure a vacation rental against its local comp set instead of a city average?
Read the answer →
How do I know if my vacation rental is priced right?
Read the answer →
How do I turn market occupancy data into an actual nightly price?
Read the answer →
How many listings should a vacation rental comp set have?
Read the answer →
Bookings have stalled on my short-term rentals. Should I drop prices or hold?
Read the answer →
When should I use a base price change versus a date override versus a seasonal profile?
Read the answer →
How do I work out my market's real low season and high season?
Read the answer →
When should I raise or relax minimum stay rules on a vacation rental?
Read the answer →
Why is my vacation rental calendar priced flat when demand clearly is not?
Read the answer →
I changed my pricing weeks ago and bookings have not improved. What now?
Read the answer →
How do I read booking pace against last year for a short-term rental market?
Read the answer →
Has my market's booking window shifted, and how should pricing react?
Read the answer →
Should weekend and weekday nights be priced differently on a vacation rental?
Read the answer →
How far below the market's 25th percentile should a struggling listing go?
Read the answer →
How do I price a unique property with no true comparables?
Read the answer →
My pricing tool's recommendations look wrong. Should I override them?
Read the answer →
How do I price around holidays and events that shift dates every year?
Read the answer →
Should date overrides be fixed prices or percentage adjustments?
Read the answer →
After cutting prices to win bookings back, how do I work them back up?
Read the answer →
Should I discount through platform promotions or lower the nightly price itself?
Read the answer →
How do I price a brand new listing with no booking history?
Read the answer →
How do I read length of stay data to set minimum stay rules?
Read the answer →
How should one pricing strategy copy across a portfolio of similar listings?
Read the answer →
Where does the booking channel's commission belong in my pricing setup?
Read the answer →
Does changing prices frequently boost ranking in booking platform search?
Read the answer →
How do I know I am actually maximizing revenue, not just staying booked?
Read the answer →
My payouts are much lower than my listed prices. Where is the money going?
Read the answer →
How do I forecast how full a date will actually end up from booking-pace data, and when should I downgrade my expectations?
Read the answer →
Should my occupancy be ahead of or behind my market's pace, and when is each fine?
Read the answer →
How do I get more weekday bookings when only my weekends sell?
Read the answer →
How do I calibrate my base price so calendar prices land where I want them?
Read the answer →
How long should my last-minute discount window be, and how steep should the discount get?
Read the answer →
How often should I review and adjust my vacation rental pricing?
Read the answer →
Is my cleaning fee too high for my market, and is it costing me bookings?
Read the answer →
Can I let a dynamic pricing tool run on autopilot, or does it still need managing?
Read the answer →
How much and how fast should I lower prices when bookings are slow?
Read the answer →
How do I know a listing is underpriced, and when should I raise prices after fast bookings?
Read the answer →
Why am I still not getting bookings after lowering my prices?
Read the answer →
How do I tell whether slow bookings are a market slowdown or a problem with my own pricing?
Read the answer →
How do I tell when my comp set is wrong and quietly skewing my prices?
Read the answer →
How do I build a comp set for a unique property with no true comparables?
Read the answer →
Should I analyze past dates or future dates when setting seasonal prices?
Read the answer →
How long should I hold my price on an unbooked date before dropping it?
Read the answer →
Should I set a maximum price cap on my listings?
Read the answer →
How should I price when new listings flood my market and demand is down year over year?
Read the answer →
How many more nights do I need to get booked to catch up with my comp set's occupancy?
Read the answer →
How do I move my weekday prices without moving my weekend prices, or the other way round?
Read the answer →
How do I set minimum-stay rules that vary by booking window and relax as the arrival date gets closer?
Read the answer →
How long should I hold a high price on a high-demand date before I start dropping it?
Read the answer →
My prices are sitting flat at my minimum price - what does that mean and what should I change?
Read the answer →
Which filters should I use when building a comp set - star rating, review count, active nights, amenities, price?
Read the answer →
What is pickup, and how do I use the last seven days of market pickup?
Read the answer →
What are healthy conversion numbers - first-page impressions, search-to-listing and listing-to-booking - and what does it mean when one is off?
Read the answer →
How does a far-out price premium work - flat or gradual, how big, and how do prices step down through the booking window?
Read the answer →
Should my comp set include listings with more or fewer bedrooms than mine, and should I match on bedrooms or on guest capacity?
Read the answer →
How do channel promotions actually work - how is the discount calculated, what are the limits, and do they boost visibility?
Read the answer →
Should I build more than one comp set - a tight one and a wider one - and compare them before choosing?
Read the answer →
How do I raise or lower only my far-out prices without touching the near-term ones?
Read the answer →
Should I judge myself against my hand-picked comp set or the tool's wider nearby-listings sample, and how do I tell if my comp set is skewed?
Read the answer →
Are the prices in my strategy hard floors, or the prices I should expect to actually get?
Read the answer →
How do I judge whether the bookings I picked up over the last week or two were a good result?
Read the answer →
Should I make an overall price change through my base price or through my minimum prices?
Read the answer →
How wide an area should my comp set cover, and where do I draw the boundary?
Read the answer →
In a weak season, should I discount early to lock in a base of occupancy rather than hold my price?
Read the answer →
What should I charge for cleaning relative to my cost and the market, and should I fold it into the nightly rate?
Read the answer →
How low is too low - will cutting my price damage my perceived value or attract the wrong kind of guest?
Read the answer →
Should I message guests who are already booked and offer them the nights either side of their stay?
Read the answer →
Why doesn't the booked rate in my data match what the guest actually paid, and should it be net of cleaning fees and taxes?
Read the answer →
How do owner blocks, off-platform bookings and one very long stay distort my occupancy and performance numbers?
Read the answer →
What do the 25th, 50th, 75th and 90th percentile price bands mean, and are they listed prices or booked prices?
Read the answer →
Should I offer weekly and monthly length-of-stay discounts, and how deep?
Read the answer →
How accurate is the market data - the estimated occupancy, revenue and activity of other listings, and which listings and bookings does it include?
Read the answer →
What non-price fixes - photos, title, description, amenities, reviews - should I make before cutting price again?
Read the answer →
My market's percentile bands are only a few dollars apart - does my price position even matter?
Read the answer →
How do I check that my prices actually reached the booking channels, and why does the site still show the old price?
Read the answer →
In what order do my pricing settings stack, and which one wins when they conflict?
Read the answer →
My property is clearly better (or worse) than anything in my comp set - can I price away from what the market data suggests?
Read the answer →
Should I accept one-night stays, and what's the downside of filling up with one- and two-night bookings?
Read the answer →
Has supply grown in my market, and how do I tell whether new supply or weaker demand is hurting me?
Read the answer →
How do I get my listing seen - what hurts my search ranking and how do I win visibility back?
Read the answer →
How do I account for local events the pricing tool doesn't know about?
Read the answer →
Why do prices fall as the stay date gets closer, and is that normal?
Read the answer →
Should I filter my comp set by amenities like a pool, hot tub or pet-friendly?
Read the answer →
Which booking channels should I list on, and why does one perform while another gives me nothing?
Read the answer →
Which cancellation policy should I use - moderate, firm or strict?
Read the answer →
How do I price a holiday or event period - which nights carry the peak, how wide should the range be, and what about the days around it?
Read the answer →
Can one comp set cover several of my properties, or does each need its own?
Read the answer →
Where should I make changes - in the pricing tool, the channel manager or the channel itself?
Read the answer →
Should I price my existing listing as though it were brand new?
Read the answer →
Should my own listing (or my other properties) be included in my comp set?
Read the answer →
Is it ever right to price at the very top of my market, above the 90th percentile?
Read the answer →
Do my direct and off-platform bookings show up in my pricing tool's data, and how do I get them counted?
Read the answer →
My calendar is nearly full and I have almost nothing left to sell - is there anything worth acting on?
Read the answer →
Should I use a different comp set for high season than for low season?
Read the answer →
Do I need a separate comp set for each booking channel, or does one cover Airbnb, Vrbo and the rest?
Read the answer →
Is there any point setting or changing prices for dates that are already booked or blocked?
Read the answer →
Why are far-out future dates priced so high, and when should I start actively managing them?
Read the answer →
Is higher occupancy at lower rates better than fewer bookings at higher rates?
Read the answer →
How do I check what individual competitors are actually charging, and which of them got booked?
Read the answer →
Should I change the tool's seasonality and demand sensitivity settings, or leave them on the default?
Read the answer →
How aggressively should I price to fill the orphan gaps between my bookings?
Read the answer →
When a nightly price comes out wrong, how do I work out which part of my setup caused it?
Read the answer →
How should I move price as a date fills up, and how big should each step be?
Read the answer →
How do I know my pricing is ready to go live on my listings?
Read the answer →
How far ahead should I open my calendar for bookings?
Read the answer →
Should I link two near-identical listings so prices copy across, and can I offset one against the other?
Read the answer →
Can I fill weak periods with demand from outside the booking sites - direct bookings, niche audiences, local businesses?
Read the answer →
Can I use market data and a comp set to size up a property I don't own yet?
Read the answer →
What are the traps with seasonal profiles - do they repeat next year, and why doesn't my seasonal price show on every date?
Read the answer →
Should I charge for early check-in or late check-out?
Read the answer →
How do I forecast when last year's data is unreliable - a regulation change, a one-off event or a shift in travel patterns?
Read the answer →
How do I plan a price to step down as a date gets closer without revisiting it every day?
Read the answer →
Should I charge extra-guest and pet fees, and how do they interact with my nightly rate?
Read the answer →
How do I price when local regulations limit my listing or force a 30-night minimum stay?
Read the answer →
How should I keep a record of what I changed each time I adjust prices?
Read the answer →
Does charm pricing - ending prices in a nine - make any difference on nightly rates?
Read the answer →
How do I handle repeat and direct-booking guests who expect last year's rate?
Read the answer →
Can I forecast my expected annual revenue, or set a revenue target, from the market data?
Read the answer →
Should I round my nightly rates, and does smoothing prices across adjacent days help?
Read the answer →
Before I strip my settings back and start over, how do I save what I have so I can revert?
Read the answer →
Should I open dates I've blocked off, and does blocking hurt me?
Read the answer →
Should I price against local hotels, and what does it mean when they cut their rates?
Read the answer →
Should I turn on instant booking, and what safeguards do I need?
Read the answer →
Want this run on your own portfolio instead of reading about it? See where each of your listings is leaving money, free.