Revenue management, answered

What should a vacation rental manager check first when owners say rates are too low?

Check whether the owner is comparing against the right set of properties and the right metric. Pull the booked nights and realized rates for their specific unit against true comps, then see if the gap is price, occupancy, or the comparison itself.

By Jack Murphy, Head of Revenue Management at UpRev. Running pricing for US vacation rental managers since 2017. Last updated November 20, 2026.

Confirm what the owner is actually looking at

Ask which number triggered the complaint. Owners often look at listed nightly rates on a competitor's page, not what those units actually booked at. Get the specific listings they have in mind, then check whether those units match on bedroom count, sleeps, view, amenities, and review standing.

Compare realized performance, not asking rates

Line up your unit's booked nights and average realized rate against the comps for the same date windows. A low asking rate that fills at good occupancy is a different problem from a low rate that fills at the last minute because the unit sat unsold earlier. I look at lead time and booking pace alongside rate, since it shows whether the unit is leaving money on the table or simply selling early.

Check the guardrails before the pricing logic

Review the minimum price, base price, seasonal minimums, and any fixed overrides set on the account. A stale floor or an old base rate set at onboarding can cap rates no matter how strong demand is. If the owner or someone on your team set manual discounts, orphan-night rules, or last-minute drops, confirm those still fit the current market. My revenue managers work inside the client's own PriceLabs account, so this is the first place we look when a rate seems out of step with demand.

Want this run for your portfolio instead of doing it yourself? See where each of your listings is leaving money, free.

Get my revenue map with Jack
Get my revenue map with Jack
Report